It's Thursday. Saturday night has a hole in it. You can offer the shift to one of your own LVNs, who is already at 36 hours this week, or call an agency for someone who has never seen the unit.
There's no single right answer. There is a sensible way to decide, and the federal overtime rules shape it.
This is general information about federal law, not legal advice. Your payroll provider or employment counsel can confirm how it applies to you.
The overtime rules that apply
The standard rule. Under the Fair Labor Standards Act, non-exempt employees get overtime at "not less than time and one-half their regular rates of pay" for hours over 40 in a workweek. A workweek is "a fixed and regularly recurring period of 168 hours," and "averaging of hours over two or more weeks is not permitted" (DOL: overtime).
The 8-and-80 option for nursing facilities. The Department of Labor says skilled nursing and other nursing care facilities may pay overtime after 40 hours in a seven-day workweek, or use the "8 and 80" system instead (DOL Fact Sheet #31). Under 8 and 80, overtime is paid for hours over 8 in a workday and over 80 in a 14-day period (29 CFR §778.601). It needs:
- An agreement or understanding with the employee, reached before the work is performed. It doesn't have to be written, but you must keep a record of it.
- A fixed 14-day period of consecutive 24-hour periods.
- A real commitment. The election must be meant to last "permanently or for a substantial period of time." Switching back and forth to cut overtime isn't allowed.
Under 8 and 80, a 12-hour shift carries 4 hours of daily overtime. So it changes the arithmetic mainly for facilities that schedule 8-hour shifts.
Who gets overtime. DOL says registered nurses paid hourly "should receive overtime pay." RNs paid on a qualifying salary may be exempt. LPNs and LVNs "generally do not qualify as exempt" (DOL Fact Sheet #17N). In most nursing facilities, the nurses you'd ask to pick up extra shifts are paid overtime.
Common mistakes DOL lists for nursing facilities (Fact Sheet #31) include:
- leaving on-call work out of overtime hours
- not paying for meal periods when the employee wasn't fully relieved of duty
- paying after 80 hours in two weeks to employees who aren't on an 8-and-80 agreement
No limit on hours. The FLSA doesn't cap how many hours an adult may work. "There is no limit in the Act on the number of hours employees aged 16 and older may work in any workweek" (DOL). The limits that matter here come from safety, not from the FLSA (below).
The cost comparison
For a single shift, compare the full cost per hour of each option:
| Your own nurse on overtime | Outside nurse | |
|---|---|---|
| Hourly cost | Regular rate × 1.5, plus payroll taxes on the premium | Agency bill rate, plus any short-notice premium |
| Orientation time | None | Your staff's time, if the nurse is new to you |
| Cancellation risk | Low; they work for you | Check your contract terms |
| Compliance paperwork | Already on file | License, background check and exclusion screening records from the agency or done by you |
The second and fourth rows are often what decide it. Our hidden cost of agency nurses worksheet helps you put numbers on them.
The limits that aren't about money
Fatigue. Texas's Standards of Nursing Practice say a nurse should accept only assignments that take into account client safety and the nurse's "physical and emotional ability" (22 TAC §217.11(1)(T)). The same rules say that a nurse who makes assignments should "Make assignments to others that take into consideration client safety" (§217.11(1)(S)). Offering a fourth twelve-hour shift to a nurse at the end of a long stretch isn't neutral just because they might say yes.
Safe Harbor. A nurse asked to accept an assignment they believe is unsafe can invoke Safe Harbor, before starting it, to request peer review. They can't be disciplined for doing so in good faith (22 TAC §217.20). The rule applies to employers that regularly employ eight or more nurses.
Turnover. Overtime that becomes routine is a scheduling problem, not a cover plan. If the same nurses carry every gap, you're spending their goodwill as well as their premium pay.
A simple decision rule
- Is anyone on your own staff under 40 hours this week, or under 8 that day on 8 and 80? Offer it to them first, at straight time.
- Has the nurse you'd ask for overtime had enough rest? If not, don't ask.
- Compare the full hourly cost of overtime and an outside nurse, using the table above.
- Prefer someone who already knows the unit. That could be your own PRN staff or an outside nurse you've used before.
- Track it monthly. If overtime and outside hours both keep climbing, the fix is in hiring or scheduling, not the next phone call. See How to Build a PRN Pool at a Small Nursing Facility.
HealthSquire is preparing a staffing pilot for independent skilled-nursing facilities in Dallas–Fort Worth, covering RN and LVN shifts. Tell us about your staffing needs.



